When You Dance with the Devil…

Senator Max Baucus is fuming. Here we are, coming down to the wire on health care reform, and the insurance industry decides to lob a stink bomb into the proceedings, claiming that rates will skyrocket if this bill passes. The dire warning is not just a prediction, of course; it’s a threat.

What are they complaining about? Haven’t insurance companies received just about everything they wanted in this bill and more? “Don’t worry,” lawmakers promised them, “by our mandating coverage, you’ll get tens of millions of new customers.” (Note: and they’re calling this “reform”?) But that’s not enough for the industry. They want everybody, and the bill’s penalties for remaining uncovered just aren’t harsh enough to compel every cow into the feedlot. Instead, insurance execs foresee being swamped with millions of uninsured, old, decrepit sick cows, not the young, healthy, leaping calves they were hoping for. And so they’ve pitched a hissy fit.

Now Baucus is scratching his head, wondering what went wrong. Like a bewildered parent of a spoiled child, he exclaims, “But I gave them everything they ever wanted!” That’s right, Senator; you did. You scuttled the public option, even though the majority of Americans desire it, and even common sense told you it’s the only way to keep costs down and create a truly competitive market. But Greed is never satisfied with just most of the pie. Didn’t you know that? That’s why it’s called Greed. When you dance with the devil, guess who always leads?

But these threats may be just what proponents of a public option have been waiting for. In holding the Senate and the American people hostage, the industry may have snatched defeat from the jaws of victory. Their mask has slipped, showing even their most loyal myrmidons in the Senate that they can’t be trusted. Like the hijacker with a box-cutter who threatens to slit his own throat if he’s not allowed to fly the plane, the insurance industry may have made a fatal error in judgment. The ancient Greeks called it hubris, pride that leads to a downfall. “Whom the gods would destroy, they first drive mad.”

Countries like Germany, France, and Switzerland had the right idea. They made for-profit insurance companies illegal, at least on the primary care level. Who ever heard of making a profit off of other people’s misery anyway?

Thank you, insurance industry. We’ve been trying to make this point for years.

Advertisements

3 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “

  1. I wish I could be optimistic, but it looks as though the teeth of the healthcare reform will come out of the Senate Finance Committee bill: the same committee that is headed by Baucus.What went wrong? The Senate, that's what.I agree with Bill Maher. It's time to take a serious look at whether the Senate is representative of the people. Each state gets 2 senators, regardless of population.The House of Representatives is FAR more representative of population size.Time to think about eliminating the Senate? Perhaps.

  2. Well, I think we have to look at the reason for the two houses. The Framers wanted to avoid "tyrannical rule by the masses" and to keep the more populous States from swamping the smaller ones. The problem is not the Constitution; it's that big business owns Congress because of current campaign financing laws. So the people's voice has been virtually eliminated from the equation. We can't compete with all that money. It will take a massive grassroots movement of outrage to change anything. The question is, just how bad do things have to get before we get outraged– and outraged at the right things? Nader has written a novel, sort of a utopian fantasy about the super-rich, like Buffett and Gates, pouring all their billions into trying to take back government. Interesting thesis, but I don't have that much faith in billionaires.

  3. I wrote my own blog on this, Steve. Let me know what you think

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s